It’s a Good Factor Penn Badgley Hates His Character in ‘You’


The actor might hate Joe Goldberg, however we nonetheless can’t get sufficient of the psychosexy sociopath Badgley brings to life within the stalker-centric rom-dram.


By Jacob Trussell · Printed on February twenty first, 2023

Appearing is an artwork kind, and behind each iconic character is an artist expressing themselves. Welcome to The Nice Performances, a recurring column exploring the artwork behind a few of cinema’s greatest roles. On this entry, Jacob Trussell explores Penn Badgley’s efficiency within the Netflix sequence You.

Have you ever ever listened to Penn Badgley discuss his character Joe Goldberg within the TV Sequence You? In that case, you’ll hear an actor describing a possibility to sink his enamel right into a frighteningly complicated character. As he informed The New York Occasions in 2019, “Joe is that this work in progress in dismantling and dissecting the myriad privileges {that a} younger, engaging, white man carries with him.”

However regardless of the function’s meatiness, Badgley doesn’t draw back from saying how he actually feels taking part in a reprehensible character.

To place it bluntly: he hates Joe. A lot in order that it’s virtually turn into an web meme.

“There’s lots I don’t get pleasure from about him. To be sincere, I don’t get pleasure from almost every part about him,” he informed DigitalSpy. “Nonetheless, it finally ends up being a deep, deep psychological exploration for me…There’s lots about him that I wrestle with, and but I’m all the time attempting to humanize him as a lot as potential.” 

As he later informed Vice, “It was type of like each considered one of my biggest fears and hopes for folks’s engagement got here to be fulfilled. There have been the reactions of overlooking all of Joe’s faults, which is the entire level of the present, and simply being actually into him. That’s, to say the least, problematic and disconcerting.” 

I discover that Badgley’s hatred of Joe inadvertently feeds his intention to humanize him. As a result of, as an actor, you need to search out the humanity within the particular person you play, nonetheless inhumane they’re. However what makes Badgley’s disdain much more fascinating is that it flies within the face of an previous performing adage. It says that, as an actor, you must strive to not choose your character. The thought is that our private judgment can impression how seamlessly we embody villainous or anti-heroic characters.

Give it some thought: do the real-life baddies ever assume they’re really the baddies? No, they assume that every part they’re doing is rational and good. As an actor, you wish to meet your character in that place, whatever the uncomfortable conditions the story might take you to.

However that doesn’t imply actors shouldn’t concentrate on who their character is manner down deep. Badgley is aware of that Joe is loathsome, and he performs that fact to a T. He has a boyish allure and piercing eyes, however behind these eyes, he hides a chilly lifelessness. This isn’t dissimilar to what Christian Bale did in American Psycho, simply toned down for the Teen Vogue set.

However inside Joe’s repulsiveness, there’s a curious streak of altruism Badgley makes use of to additional humanize his character. We all know, to paraphrase Badgley’s personal phrases, that Joe is a sociopathic, abusive, delusional, self-obsessed assassin. But we’re nonetheless moved by the moments when Badgley’s character is confronted by recollections of his traumatic childhood.

And oh boy, did Joe have a unhealthy time rising up. He murdered his abusive dad and was deserted by his mother. Then, when he’s in his teenagers, he’s taken in by a bookkeeper, Mr. Mooney (Mark Blum). However the place his actual father was bodily abusive, Joe’s new father determine was psychologically abusive. As a type of punishment, Mooney locks Joe in a glass cage within the basement of his bookstore. Mooney needs Joe to “study from wiser males” by forcing him to learn the basic books that fill his clear jail.

These are the traumatic occasions that formed Badgley’s Joe for worse and for higher. The way it turned him right into a sociopath, effectively, the proof is within the pudding. However the way in which that trauma molded Joe into a greater man is it made him compassionate in the direction of kids. Particularly, these trapped in shitty conditions that remind him of his personal, like Paco (Luca Padovan) or Ellie (Jenna Ortega). And when Joe senses they’re at risk, Badgley will get to erupt in a present of efficient feelings. He channels his character’s psychopathic tendencies into one thing that resembles altruism–albeit murderous altruism.

This altruistic factor is why the web has drawn strains between Badgley’s Joe and Michael C. Corridor’s Dexter Morgan. However despite the fact that Joe murders unhealthy guys, a serial killer of serial killers, he isn’t. Joe doesn’t have a code like Dexter, understanding the exhausting line between proper and flawed. No, Joe remains to be a gross sociopathic stalker who, irrespective of how a lot he tries to guard the untrodden, remains to be only a twisted little psychopath. And Badgley makes certain we see that Joe’s psychopathic tendencies, as a lot as his altruistic ones, had been all the time intentional.

We see it in a flashback to his first “huge boy homicide” after discovering his girlfriend, Candace (Ambyr Childers), was sleeping with one other man. After confronting the man, relatively than getting macho pushback, the person relents, saying he had no thought Candace was with another person. A way of resignation falls over Badgley’s face after this unusual, brotherly response. It places Joe instantly off guard, his fuming rage dissipating as he sullenly walks away. 

However because the dudebro begins disparaging Candace’s identify, Badgley reveals an nearly imperceptible shift in Joe’s power. We see his face gentle up with decisiveness. He is going to do what he initially got down to do and kill the douchebag. He rapidly turns round and shoves the person off of a excessive ledge. This second is so electrical as a result of Badgley doesn’t play Joe as if he has uncontrollable rage. As an alternative, Badgley ensures we see Joe deliberately cross the road between proper and flawed and by no means look again once more.

Whereas You is now a Netflix present, its first season really aired on Lifetime, the community devoted to melodramatic cheesiness. That sensibility is actually on show throughout each season of You. However Penn Badgley’s Joe Goldberg isn’t a melodramatic madman who commits crimes of ardour. Joe does what he does intentionally and with surgeon-like care, and Badgley carries that sensibility in his efficiency all through each episode of the sequence. However all of Joe’s murderous faults can be grating if not for Badgley’s highly effective efficiency. He might in the end hate his character, however that has solely made audiences love Joe Goldberg much more.

Associated Matters: The Nice Performances

Jacob Trussell is a author based mostly in New York Metropolis. His editorial work has been featured on the BBC, NPR, Rue Morgue Journal, Movie Faculty Rejects, and One Excellent Shot. He is additionally the creator of ‘The Binge Watcher’s Information to The Twilight Zone’ (Riverdale Avenue Books). Obtainable to host your subsequent spooky public entry present. Discover him on Twitter right here: @JE_TRUSSELL (He/Him)


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:



More like this